No concussion substitute trials to take place during FA Cup third round
Concussion substitutes will not be used in the FA Cup third round, the PA news agency understands.
The Football Association announced last month its intention to trial the use of up to two additional permanent concussion substitutes per team in its flagship competition at “the earliest possible stage”.
However, it is understood the full protocol has not yet been received from the game’s law-making body, the International Football Association Board (IFAB).
[2/3] The FA will support the IFAB FAP-TAP’s proposal at the forthcoming IFAB Annual Business Meeting on 16 December 2020 with a view to implementing the trials at the earliest possible stages of the 2020/21 Emirates FA Cup and Vitality Women’s FA Cup.
— FA Spokesperson (@FAspokesperson) November 23, 2020
That means the trial will not begin until the fourth round at the earliest.
FA chief executive Mark Bullingham said last month: “In terms of how quickly we can bring it down, we’ve got to wait until IFAB writes up the protocol.
“If we’re talking about the FA Cup, it will either be the third round or fourth round depending on how quickly we can process everything.”
Under the protocol, the opposition is allowed to make a change to compensate for each concussion substitute used.
The IFAB protocols have been criticised by neurologist Dr Willie Stewart, who does not think they do enough to protect players from the risk of secondary concussion and described them as “putting lipstick on a pig”.
Along with world players’ union FIFPRO, Stewart has called for a longer on-pitch assessment period.
Lipstick on a pig is new development too and about as useful to #concussion mgmt as @TheIFAB proposal to maintain status quo w medical team time to assess without added pressure.
But we will have lipstick trial and in 1y(?more) either be stuck here or inch slowly forward. pic.twitter.com/7GUOGJTAOC
— Dr Willie Stewart (@WillStewNeuro) December 16, 2020
Bullingham defended the protocol when he talked about it last month, adding: “I’m really surprised this is seen as a cop out. I see this as going further.
“We’re taking any player that is suspected of concussion off the pitch. I don’t follow the logic there.
“I understand there are two models that have got different values but, from our point of view, we see this as a stronger model, the safer model, and that’s what we’re being advised by the medical experts.”
Clubs will be able to use up to five substitutes in a match after the FA adopted the temporary amendment to the laws of the game, with nine subs permitted on the bench. There will be no additional changes allowed if a match goes to extra-time.
