Civil Service union starts judicial review into PM’s decision to stand by Patel

Patrick Daly

A union representing senior public servants is set to go to court to challenge Boris Johnson’s decision to stand by the Home Secretary following a bullying furore.

The FDA union has started a judicial review to “overturn” the Prime Minister’s decision to disregard the findings of his adviser on ministerial standards in order to back Priti Patel last year.

Sir Alex Allan left his advisory role in Downing Street after Mr Johnson contradicted his advice by judging that Ms Patel did not breach the rules despite being found to have bullied staff.

In an investigation into Ms Patel’s behaviour published in November, Sir Alex found that the Cabinet minister had not always treated civil servants with “consideration and respect”.

Sir Alex concluded that Ms Patel’s behaviour, which was said to include some occasions of shouting and swearing, met the definition of bullying adopted by the Civil Service.

Ministers are usually expected to resign if they breach the code but Mr Johnson, who is its arbiter, judged, in a decision that is being challenged by the FDA, that Ms Patel had not fallen foul of the rules.

Dave Penman, the union’s general secretary, said the affair had obliterated Civil Service trust in the ministerial code.

He said a survey taken since of FDA members who are most likely to work with ministers found that nearly 90% said they had no confidence in the ministerial code as a mechanism for dealing with bullying and harassment by ministers.

Prime Minister Boris Johnson overruled his adviser on ministerial standards
Prime Minister Boris Johnson overruled his adviser on ministerial standards (Stefan Rousseau/PA)

Mr Penman added: “In November the Prime Minister made the extraordinary decision that the Home Secretary did not breach the ministerial code, despite clear evidence that she bullied civil servants.

“As the union that represents many of the staff who work day to day with ministers, we cannot simply let this issue rest.

“Civil servants should expect to work with ministers without fear of being bullied or harassed.

“(Mr Johnson’s) decision, which he said reflected the Home Secretary’s assertion that her actions were unintentional, potentially allows ministers to avoid the consequences of their behaviour in future by pleading that it should be the intent of their actions which is important, not the consequences.

“Our judicial review, launched today, would seek to overturn the Prime Minister’s decision that the Home Secretary’s conduct did not breach the ministerial code.

“This is not about whether the Home Secretary should be forced to resign, that is a matter for the Prime Minister, this is simply about how the ministerial code is interpreted.”

Following the publication of Sir Alex’s report, Ms Patel issued an “unreserved, fulsome apology” and said there were “no excuses” for what happened.

Mr Johnson later wrote to ministers and heads of Government departments reminding them that there is “no place for bullying”.

From Our Partners