Shamed ex-minister Aitken asked judge to show mercy to ‘naughty Tory’ Elphicke
Disgraced former cabinet minister Jonathan Aitken was among those leaping to the defence of ex-Tory MP Charlie Elphicke after his conviction for sexually assaulting women, court documents show.
Aitken, who was jailed in 1999 after admitting perjury and perverting the course of justice, was among those who sent testimonies on behalf of his friend ahead of Elphicke’s sentencing at Southwark Crown Court in September.
Aitken also said he offered Elphicke “some advice” about being a prisoner, but pleaded for the court to exercise “mercy”.
Elphicke, 49, the former MP for Dover, was jailed for two years after he was convicted of three counts of assault against two women, during which he was alleged to have described himself as “a naughty Tory”.
He was described by judge Mrs Justice Whipple as a “sexual predator” who “told a pack of lies” to jurors.
Character references were mentioned in court by defence counsel Ian Winter QC, though the identities of the providers were not disclosed until Wednesday when Mrs Justice Whipple agreed to a representation by the media to have them released.
In one reference, Aitken, who was later ordained to become a prison chaplain, drew on his own experiences in jail in his submission to the court.
He wrote: “The adjective ‘kind’ was often applied to Charles Elphicke in his constituency because of his caring attitude to the casework that he handled.
“In the last few weeks, since his conviction, I have seen and talked to Charles Elphicke for personal and pastoral reasons.
“As a former prisoner and now a prison chaplain myself I have been able to offer him some advice and guidance on how to handle the life of a prisoner if he should be given a custodial sentence.
“I have also had spiritual conversations with him. He is a committed Christian and regular churchgoer.
“He has made it clear to me that he is deeply remorseful for his failings of character and behaviour which have led to his conviction.
“I am certain that his penitence is sincere. I hope and pray the court will temper justice with mercy when handing down its sentence.”
Other character references included one from a local Catholic priest, Father Jeff Cridland, who suggested the judge suspend Elphicke’s sentence, writing: “Too much of a shaking is not a good thing.”
Others included David Foley, chief executive of Dover District Chamber of Commerce, Kent County Councillor Nigel Collor, a retired local Tory party case worker, and a third-year politics student.
The most senior judge in England and Wales, the Lord Chief Justice, last week renewed his criticism of a group of Conservative MPs who sought to influence Mrs Justice Whipple’s decision over whether to release the character references.
Five politicians – MPs Sir Roger Gale, Adam Holloway, Colonel Bob Stewart and ex-environment secretary Theresa Villiers, along with peer Lord Freud – subsequently self-published their own references following the media application.
Natalie Elphicke, Elphicke’s estranged wife and his successor as Dover MP, who did not give evidence during the trial, joined the quintet in adding her name to a letter to senior judges warning that publishing the character statements could “deter” people from providing similar background details in future cases.
The court heard that some of the referees were given assurances that their references would be “for the judge’s eyes only”, but it was not ascertained how they came to believe that.