Anne Sacoolas’s diplomatic immunity claim an absurdity – diplomacy expert

An expert on diplomacy has described the diplomatic immunity claim from Harry Dunn's alleged killer as a "palpable absurdity".

Anne Sacoolas claimed diplomatic immunity after the teenager died in a crash outside a US military base in Northamptonshire on August 27.

Sir Ivor Roberts, a former British ambassador in Serbia, Ireland and Italy, said it was "wholly illogical ... to waive immunity for a member of staff" at RAF Croughton and "not to do so for a member of his or her household".

Harry Dunn
Sir Ivor Roberts said the immunity claimed by Anne Sacoolas was a 'palpable absurdity' (Chris Bacon/PA)

Sacoolas's claim to immunity is set to be the subject of a judicial review trial in which Mr Dunn's parents, Charlotte Charles and Tim Dunn, allege Foreign Secretary Dominic Raab acted unlawfully over the suspect's departure from the UK.

The Dunn family claims that Sacoolas – in line with agreements made between the UK and the US – should have had her claim to immunity pre-waived.

The Foreign Office argues that – because Sacoolas was notified to them as a spouse – and dependants were not mentioned in the so-called Exchange of Notes, her immunity was not pre-waived, in what they have described as an "anomaly".

A former junior minister at the Foreign Office (FCO), Sir Tony Baldry, who signed the agreement with the US covering RAF Croughton, also said he believed FCO lawyers would not have "created a situation whereby immunity was waived for agents outside work, but not for their spouses".

In his witness statement, he said: "We were obviously extremely unhappy at the prospect of technicians and their dependants being placed above the law and this I made clear by instructing that any agreement must be conditional upon the waiver.

Harry Dunn
Sir Tony Baldry also said he believed FCO lawyers would not have created a situation in which staff had immunity waived but spouses did not (Dominic Lipinski/PA)

"I am sure that the US did not and would not have raised any specific request for dependants to be exempted from the law – had they done so I would have refused or at the very least referred this matter to the Secretary of State for him to decide.

"I cannot imagine any government agreeing to such an arrangement."

Sir Tony's evidence will be heard at a judicial review trial in October or November but Lord Justice Flaux dismissed an application to include Sir Ivor's evidence.

Before the application was dismissed, Sir Ivor said in a statement: "It is wholly illogical and against any sensible interpretation of the Vienna Convention to waive immunity for a member of staff and not to do so for a member of his or her household.

"This could lead to the absurd position whereby if Mr Sacoolas had taken a Sunday afternoon drive, ie. not on official business, and had had the accident with Harry Dunn, he would not enjoy immunity from criminal jurisdiction but were his wife driving and he were the passenger, she would enjoy that immunity.

Harry Dunn death
The teenager's family say Sacoolas should have had her immunity pre-waived (David Mirzoeff/PA)

"In a more extreme example of domestic violence, were the US official to kill his wife after a domestic argument he would not enjoy immunity from criminal jurisdiction whereas if the roles were reversed and she killed him, she would benefit from immunity. A palpable absurdity."

Speaking on behalf of the Dunn family, spokesman Radd Seiger told the PA news agency: "It is now overwhelmingly clear how Harry Dunn's parents find themselves in the appalling situation they are in, without justice, without closure.

"They lost their son 10 months ago and the person who took his life was allowed to walk away.

"But the minister responsible at the time and one of this country's leading diplomatic immunity experts now make it clear that Anne Sacoolas did not have diplomatic immunity at the time of the crash with Harry Dunn."

30 PHOTOS
Pictures of the week: June 21 - June 27
See Gallery
Pictures of the week: June 21 - June 27
Liverpool fan Dillon Parry waves a flag outside Anfield in Liverpool. (Photo by Martin Rickett/PA Images via Getty Images)
A man clears rubbish left by beachgoers in Brighton as thunderstorms and torrential rain are forecast to sweep across the UK, bringing an end to a week of blazing sunshine and scorching temperatures.
A man jumps into a disused dock in East London as Thursday could be the UK's hottest day of the year with scorching temperatures forecast to rise even further.
Sunbathers at Richmond Bridge, London, as Thursday could be the UK's hottest day of the year with scorching temperatures forecast to rise even further.
A man wearing a face mask seen with his children at the beach on the hottest day of the year. People head to the beach at the popular seaside resort of Skegness as England records it's hottest day of the year with temperatures at 30 degrees Celsius. (Photo by Keith Mayhew / SOPA Images/Sipa USA)
Protesters singing songs during the demonstration. Protesters from the �Africans in the Diaspora� gather outside Christie's to demand the return of African Artifacts. Europe's museums are fighting to keep Africa's artifacts as pressure mounts from campaigners. (Photo by Thabo Jaiyesimi / SOPA Images/Sipa USA)
People play in the River Cam in Grantchester near Cambridge as Thursday could be the UK's hottest day of the year with scorching temperatures forecast to rise even further.
People in Clapham Common, south London as Thursday could be the UK's hottest day of the year with scorching temperatures forecast to rise even further.
Crowds gather on the beach in Bournemouth as Thursday could be the UK's hottest day of the year with scorching temperatures forecast to rise even further.
RICKMANSWORTH, ENGLAND - JUNE 25: Amateur Annabell Fuller hits her second shot on the 1st hole during The Rose Ladies Series at Moor Park Golf Club on June 25, 2020 in Rickmansworth, England. (Photo by Richard Heathcote/Getty Images)
Andy Meldrum, owner of the Glencoe Mountain Resort, skis on some of the remaining snow patches on the slopes of Meall a'Bhuiridh in Glencoe as Thursday could be the UK's hottest day of the year with scorching temperatures forecast to rise even further.
Cows use the River Thames to cool off in Bourne End, Bucks, as Thursday could be the UK's hottest day of the year with scorching temperatures forecast to rise even further.
LONDON, ENGLAND - JUNE 25: Kyle Edmund (R) and James Ward both leave the ball for each other during their doubles match against Joe Salisbury and Jonny O'Mara on day 3 of Schroders Battle of the Brits at the National Tennis Centre on June 25, 2020 in London, England. (Photo by Clive Brunskill/Getty Images for Battle Of The Brits)
A pair of women wearing face masks turn onto Old Quebec Street from Oxford Street in London, England, on June 23, 2020. British Prime Minister Boris Johnson announced today that the next stage of lockdown easing in England would proceed on schedule, with pubs, restaurants, hotels, hairdressers, theatres, cinemas, museums, galleries, libraries, theme parks and zoos allowed to reopen from July 4. The two-metre social distancing rule is also to be halved from the same date, with people encouraged to take additional mitigation actions, such as wearing face coverings, when close together. The change, to what is being dubbed 'one-metre plus', is seen as key to the survival of the hospitality sector. (Photo by David Cliff/NurPhoto via Getty Images)
A homeless man sleeps on Cranbourn Street in London, England, on June 23, 2020. British Prime Minister Boris Johnson announced today that the next stage of lockdown easing in England would proceed on schedule, with pubs, restaurants, hotels, hairdressers, theatres, cinemas, museums, galleries, libraries, theme parks and zoos allowed to reopen from July 4. The two-metre social distancing rule is also to be halved from the same date, with people encouraged to take additional mitigation actions, such as wearing face coverings, when close together. The change, to what is being dubbed 'one-metre plus', is seen as key to the survival of the hospitality sector. (Photo by David Cliff/NurPhoto via Getty Images)
The RAF Voyager used by the Prime Minister and the royal family taxies along the runway at Cambridge airport where it has been repainted in the colours of the Union flag at a cost of almost £1 million. (Photo by Stefan Rousseau/PA Images via Getty Images)
PERMISSION GIVEN A couple relax outside their beach hut on the beach in Bournemouth, Dorset, as Britain is braced for a June heatwave with temperatures set to climb into the mid-30s this week. (Photo by Andrew Matthews/PA Images via Getty Images)
View of a field of poppies in the summer sunshine. (Photo by Keith Mayhew / SOPA Images/Sipa USA)
People sit in prayer in the nave of Worcester Cathedral in Worcester, Worcestershire, as it opens for the first time since the UK entered lockdown to reduce the spread of coronavirus.
Equestrian statue of the Duke of Cambridge in Whitehall is being cleaned after it was graffitied with a slogan BLM. Clean up of historical statues after fourth consecutive week of Black Lives Matter protests in London. (Photo by Thabo Jaiyesimi / SOPA Images/Sipa USA)
Police officers congregate outside a cordoned off block of flats where the suspect of a multiple stabbing incident lived in Reading, west of London, on June 23, 2020. - British counter-terrorism police have been given until June 27 to question a suspect widely identified as Libyan Khairi Saadallah in an attack which saw three people stabbed to death in a park, officers said. (Photo by Ben STANSALL / AFP) (Photo by BEN STANSALL/AFP via Getty Images)
People visit the beach in Boscombe, as Britain is braced for a June heatwave as temperatures are set to climb into the mid-30s this week. (Photo by Andrew Matthews/PA Images via Getty Images)
BEVERLEY, ENGLAND - JUNE 23: Jockey Danny Tudhope riding Le Chiffre approach the finish line to win the William Hill Lengthen #yourodds Handicap (Div I) at Beverley Racecourse on June 23, 2020 in Beverley, England. (Photo by Hannah Ali/Pool via Getty Images)
Twilight at dawn at New Brighton lighthouse during low tide on the River Mersey ahead of the chance that Britain could bask in the hottest day of the year so far this week. (Photo by Peter Byrne/PA Images via Getty Images)
The Statue Robert Clive is boarded up following vandalism from previous demonstration in the City. Clive, the 1st Baron Clive better know as Clive of India, who established British rule in India stands outside the Foreign Office. Clive was first Governor of Bengal Presidency under the East India Company. Authorities boarded monuments and statues in London most due to their past linkage to slavery in anticipation of possible vandalism with far-right organisations and Black Lives Matter demonstration scheduled for this weekend. (Photo by David Mbiyu / SOPA Images/Sipa USA)
Black lives matter protester holds a placard during the demonstration. Protests continue in London and elsewhere in the UK for the fourth consecutive week amid growing calls for reform in police forces. (Photo by Thabo Jaiyesimi / SOPA Images/Sipa USA)
People camp under a bivouac during showers next to a closed Stonehenge as people gather to celebrate the dawn of the longest day in the UK.
READING , June 21, 2020 -- A police officer stands behind a police cordon at an entrance to Forbury Gardens where stabbings took place in Reading, Britain, on June 21, 2020. Britain's counter-terrorism police said Sunday that the stabbing incident taking place in southern England's town of Reading on Saturday night "has now been declared a terrorist incident."(Photo by Tim Ireland/Xinhua via Getty) (Xinhua/ via Getty Images)
LIVERPOOL, ENGLAND - JUNE 21: Liverpool fan Emily Farley poses outside her home which is decorated in club flags, banners and paraphernalia before the Premier League match between Everton FC and Liverpool FC at Goodison Park on June 21, 2020 in Liverpool, United Kingdom. (Photo by Simon Stacpoole/Offside/Offside via Getty Images)
BLM demonstrators march through Oxford Street during the demonstration. Black Lives Matter protests continue in The UK since the death of George Floyd at the hands of police officer in Minneapolis. (Photo by David Mbiyu / SOPA Images/Sipa USA)
HIDE CAPTION
SHOW CAPTION
of
SEE ALL
BACK TO SLIDE

Read Full Story Click here to comment

FROM OUR PARTNERS