Passport photo checker falsely mistook black man's lips for open mouth

Two United Kingdom Passports

A black man who tried to renew his passport online was stunned when the automated passport photo checker mistook his lips for an open mouth.

Joshua Bada used a high quality photo booth image to apply for his passport, with a digital code that he had to note down and enter on

The facial detection system informs people when it thinks the photo uploaded may not meet strict requirements, which include a plain expression and the mouth to be kept closed.

After Bada's picture was taken, the message that appeared on the screen told him: "It looks like your mouth is open".

The 28-year-old from west London said that it was not the first time technology had issues with the size of his lips.

Joshua Bada used a high quality photo booth image to apply for his passport, with a digital code that he had to note down and enter on (PA)

"When I saw it, I was a bit annoyed but it didn't surprise me because it's a problem that I have faced on Snapchat with the filters, where it hasn't quite recognised my mouth, obviously because of my complexion and just the way my features are," he explained.

"After I posted it online, friends started getting in contact with me, saying, it's funny but it shouldn't be happening."

When asked by the system if he wanted to submit the photo anyway, Mr Bada was forced to explain why in a comment box, writing: "My mouth is closed, I just have big lips."

The incident is not an isolated case – in April, a black woman shared a post on Twitter of similar struggles with facial recognition technology.

World's most powerful passports
See Gallery
World's most powerful passports
Japan has the most powerful passport in the world. Source: Getty Images
Red Singapore passport
Studio shot of a set of french identification documents. From front to back, a
German passports most powerful
Two South Korean passports isolated on a white background.
Four Danish Passports. Red European Community Passports.
finnish passport
An italian passport out of the pocket of denim trousers
Detail of an spanish passport. Documentation for travelers
Swedish passport folded on wood rustic background.
'Electronic passport with some Euro/Thai money and a Thai Arrival Card, isolated on white background'
Close-up on a Luxembourg passport isolated on a white background.
Two dutch passports on wooden tabletop.
Regular Norwegian passports are burgundy in colour, with the Norway Coat of arms emblazoned in the top of the front cover. The new biometric Norwegian passport has the standard biometric symbol at the bottom.
Portuguese Passport cover, with European Union burgundy color - Portugal's biometric passport - An ePassport aka digital passport uses contactless smart card technology to store the identity data of the traveler - photo by M.Torres
Everything you need to know about passports and visas after Brexit
Photo Taken In United States, Dallas
Passports rankings

Cat Hallam, an educational technologist from Staffordshire, stressed that she does not believe it amounts to racism, but thinks it is a result of algorithmic bias.

She became frustrated after the system told her it looked like her eyes are closed and that it could not find the outline of her head.

"How many other individuals are probably either spending money unnecessarily or having to go through the process on numerous occasions of a system that really should be able to factor in a broad range of ethnicities?" she explained.

Ms Hallam proceeded with one of the images and received her passport without any further problems.

When posting about the issue on Twitter at the time, the Passport Office tweeted back to her, saying it was sorry the photo upload service hadn't "worked as it should".

The Home Office responded saying: "We are determined to make the experience of uploading a digital photograph as simple as possible, and will continue working to improve this process for all of our customers.

"In the vast majority of cases where a photo does not pass our automated check, customers may override the outcome and submit the photo as part of their application.

Lack of diversity in the workplace

"The photo checker is a customer aide that is designed to check a photograph meets the internationally agreed standards for passports."

Noel Sharkey, professor of artificial intelligence and robotics at the University of Sheffield, believes lack of diversity in the workplace and an unrepresentative sample of black people is one of the reasons why the error may have happened.

"We know that automated systems have problems with gender as well, it has a real problem with women too generally, and if you're a black woman you're screwed, it's really bad, it's not fit for purpose and I think it's time that people started recognising that," he said.

"People have been struggling for a solution for this in all sorts of algorithmic bias, not just face recognition, but algorithmic bias in decisions for mortgages, loans, and everything else and it's still happening."

The Race Equality Foundation said it believes the system was not tested properly to see if it would actually work for black or ethnic minority people, calling it "technological or digital racism".

"Presumably there was a process behind developing this type of technology which did not address issues of race ethnicity and as a result it disadvantages black and minority ethnic people," Samir Jeraj, the charity's policy and practice officer, commented.

- This article first appeared on Yahoo

Read Full Story