Should you give Cash ISAs a miss this year?

Cash ISA rates are pitiful and you can earn tax-free returns on your savings elsewhere. So should you opt for a Stocks and Shares ISA instead?

Updated: 

ISA season: Should you give Cash ISAs a miss this year?

The new tax year has started and savvy people are on the lookout for the best places to put their money and use up their new £20,000 tax-free ISA allowance.

But, rather than putting it in a Cash ISA, here's why you should consider using your allowance on a Stocks and Shares ISA instead.

Better returns

Interest rates really are pitiful at the moment. The best-buy instant access account pays a mere 1.1%.

In contrast, the FTSE 100 rose by 19% over the past year.

Past performance isn't a guarantee of future growth, but historically the stock market outperforms cash.

Investment firm M&G found that, for every £1 you invested in shares in 1983 and tracked the rise in the FTSE all-share index, you would have an inflation-adjusted sum of £11.66 by the end of last year.

By contrast, each £1 held in a savings account would be worth just £1.33 once you factored in inflation.

The Personal Savings Allowance

The arrival of the Personal Savings Allowance last year means most people can now enjoy tax-free returns on their savings even if they aren't held in a Cash ISA.

The allowance means basic rate taxpayers can earn up to £1,000 interest a year before income tax is due.

Higher rate taxpayers have a smaller allowance of £500 a year, while additional rate taxpayers miss out completely.

That means a basic rate taxpayer can put more than £90,000 in savings and current accounts before they have to worry about exceeding the savings allowance.

Given that the interest rates on traditional savings and current accounts are currently higher than the best rates available on Cash ISAs, it makes it difficult to argue for keeping any savings you do wish to hold in a Cash ISA.

The Dividend Allowance

If you are currently holding investments outside of an ISA you may want to move them into one in order to protect your dividends from the taxman.

The Chancellor announced in his Budget that the Dividend Allowance will be cut next April to £2,000.

At present investors can earn up to £5,000 a year in dividends before they have to pay tax, but the cut will mean many will face a bigger tax bill next year.

Investments held within an ISA are free from dividend tax as well as capital growth.

Freedom to change your mind

Finally, if you put your full ISA allowance in an investment ISA it isn't locked away.

If you change your mind you can move it back into a Cash ISA at any point.

Everyone has different needs

So there you have it; four reasons to consider using your allowance on a Stocks and Shares ISA.

Now, it's worth pointing out that this strategy certainly won't work for everyone.

If, for example, you simply aren't comfortable with taking on risk or don't qualify for the Personal Savings Allowance, Cash ISAs can still form part of your saving strategy.

Everyone has different needs, and some will find Cash ISAs more useful than others.

Looking to invest? Compare fees across a whole host of companies at a glance at loveMONEY.com (capital at risk)