When Dave Lewis was parachuted in to oversee Tesco's(LSE: TSCO) turnaround efforts in 2014, the experienced retail manager had a daunting task ahead of him.
Nearly two years on and you could be forgiven for thinking Tesco's recovery is complete; that is if you base your view of its health on Dave Lewis's compensation package.
Last year Mr Lewis was awarded £4.6m in compensation, including 96% of his maximum possible bonus after beating internal goals for sales and profit, and improving the supermarket's relationship with suppliers.
Granted, the company has come a long way since Lewis took over in 2014. During the past two years, Tesco has scrapped its dividend, closed 60 unprofitable stores, abandoned 49 store developments, cut its rent bill by buying back 70 leasehold stores and two distribution centres, and strengthened its balance sheet with the £4bn from its South Korean business. What's more, the company is on track to lower costs by merging two head offices and has rejigged its pension scheme to reduce liabilities.
These are all significant changes, but when it comes to the top and bottom lines, Tesco is still struggling.
Struggling where it counts
During Dave Lewis's first full year in charge of the retailer, Tesco reported its first quarter of like-for-like sales growth in three years and posted annual pre-tax profits of £164m. These figures look impressive when you compare this performance to the reported loss of £6.4bn for 2014, a year that was skewed by one-off items. But the numbers don't look so impressive when you consider the fact that Tesco reported a pre-tax profit of £2.3bn for 2014.
And there are concerns that Tesco's figures could begin to deteriorate again this year.
About to get worse?
According to City broker JPMorgan Cazenove, Tesco's figures for 2015 were flattered by the fact that the group paid no corporation tax for the year, and one-off items such as the sale of Blinkbox, Tesco's lossmaking video service, and a reclassification of ATM income from the bank to the retail division. Moreover, despite Tesco's drive to cut costs JPMorgan believes that the introduction of the UK's new living wage (along with other factors) will push Tesco's operating costs higher by £200m per annum in the years ahead. Higher costs going forward could floor Tesco's recovery especially when it's widely believed that supermarkets are about to embark on yet another price war.
So overall, while Dave Lewis's pay packet may indicate that Tesco's recovery is in full swing, on the ground the company still has a long way to go before management can claim to have stabilised the business. Investors may also feel shortchanged as during Mr Lewis's first full year as CEO, shares in Tesco lost 28% of their value. Over the past 12 months, the shares have lost a quarter of their value.
But don't just take my word for it, to help you assess Tesco for yourself, our top analysts have put together this report, which guides you through the 10 essential steps you need to succeed in the stock market.
The report explains how spending just 20 minutes a month could help you create a portfolio that could bring you closer to financial freedom for life.
Click here to check out the report - it's completely free and comes with no further obligation.
Rupert Hargreaves has no position in any shares mentioned. The Motley Fool UK has no position in any of the shares mentioned. We Fools don't all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors.