Watchdog report on BBC pay criticised as ‘whitewash’

An investigation which found no unlawful acts of pay discrimination at the BBC despite high-profile payouts to female staff has been labelled a "whitewash".

The Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) said that "the processes" to deal with pay grievances at the broadcaster "let women down". It added that many who queried their pay suffered "humiliation, anxiety, insomnia".

But its report did not find any breaches of the law, despite a torrid few years for the BBC on the issue.

The watchdog published its findings on equal pay – defined as the same pay for equal work – after selecting 10 cases from 2017 to 2019 to look at in depth.

The report was published just months after Newswatch presenter Samira Ahmed won a sex discrimination equal pay claim against the broadcaster at a tribunal.

Other high profile cases include Radio 4 presenter Sarah Montague, who received a £400,000 settlement and an apology over unequal treatment.

Broadcaster Carrie Gracie was also given an apology and back pay after resigning from her position as China editor in 2018 in protest at pay inequalities.

The broadcaster has made over 500 pay revisions for women in recent years – although it said the majority of these are for "fair pay" so are not to do with gender.

The BBC has said it identified 39 cases of unequal pay, which it "corrected".

BBC Women, a group of more than 150 broadcasters and producers at the corporation, said they were "deeply disappointed by the findings that do not reflect our experiences".

"New cases are coming forward and women are still heading to court. We fight on," they said.

Gracie, who recently left the BBC, wrote on Twitter: "EHRC report on BBC equal pay feels like whitewash.

"Examined just 10 cases... Seriously? FOLLOW THE ££ INSTEAD: BBC forced to pay out to 100s of BBC women.

"Moral of story: don't rely on regulator but stay strong, calm, united + JUSTICE WILL PREVAIL."

And a BBC insider told the PA news agency there was "puzzlement" that the watchdog "had apparently ignored the cases where the BBC has settled".

They added that "nothing alters the fact that 500 had women had pay rises" in recent years.

The watchdog defended its investigation, saying it was "very confident" in its "robust findings".

But Joanna Gregson, head of enforcement at the EHRC, said that despite finding no "pay discrimination" in the cases that were looked at, "that's not to say it didn't happen elsewhere (at the BBC)".

Pictures of the week: November 8 - 14
See Gallery
Pictures of the week: November 8 - 14
Vinegar Strokes and Courtney Act take part a photocall for Death Drop: A Dragatha Christie Murder Mystery at the Garrick Theatre in London. (Photo by Brett Cove / SOPA Images/Sipa USA)
A view of the Covent Garden?s Infinity Chamber that encourages visitors to take five minutes out of their busy day and indulge in restorative colour therapy. Created using thousands of LED bulbs which will change colours throughout the day from beautiful bright white to an ever changing rainbow. The Infinity Chamber is free for visitors to use 24 hours a day, making it the first of its kind in London . (Photo by Keith Mayhew / SOPA Images/Sipa USA)
A man cleans windows above The North Face store in London?s Covent Garden while abseiling down the side. (Photo by Dave Rushen / SOPA Images/Sipa USA)
Scotland's David Marshall saving from Serbia's Aleksandar Mitrovic to win the penalty shoot and qualifying for the Euro2020 finals following the UEFA Euro 2020 Play-off Finals match at Rajko Mitic Stadium, Belgrade.
Residents and care workers at Churchview Nursing Home in Liverpool watch a video of this year's christmas lights switch on in Liverpool city centre. The video was created for people isolating at home, in care homes or for those who are unable to get into the city centre due to the current coronavirus lockdown in England. (Photo by Peter Byrne/PA Images via Getty Images)
A Westminster council worker sweeps up fallen leaves in the Aldwych in London. (Photo by Dave Rushen / SOPA Images/Sipa USA)
GREAT MISSENDEN , ENGLAND - NOVEMBER 11: HS2 contractors at the site of tree felling at a section of an Iron Age earthwork known as Grim's Ditch, scheduled as an 'Ancient Monument', that will be destroyed by the HS2 High Speed Rail line, on November 11, 2020 in Great Missenden, England. ‘Scheduling’ gives an archaeological site the highest level of protection that the state can give, but the HS2 Hybrid Bill allows previous protective legislation to be set aside and this 120-metre section of Grim's Ditch will be destroyed. Much of the countryside around the surrounding Misbourne Valley and Aylesbury Vale is also under threat from the controversial HS2 project. HS2 protesters continue to occupy key infrastructure sites along the proposed HS2 route claiming that the project is "the most carbon-intensive and environmentally destructive project in UK history." (Photo by Jim Dyson/Getty Images)
Britain's Camilla Duchess of Cornwall leaves after attending the Armistice Day service at Westminster Abbey in London, Wednesday, Nov. 11, 2020. The specially arranged service, with social distancing because of the coronavirus, commemorates the 102nd anniversary of the armistice ending World War I, and one hundred years since the symbolic interment of the Unknown Warrior at Westminster Abbey. (Aaron Chown/Pool via AP)
LONDON, UNITED KINGDOM - NOVEMBER 11: Police officers cordon off the area after a car crashed to the police station in London, United Kingdom on November 11, 2020. (Photo by Bilal Acar/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images)
A giant poppy seen at King's Cross station. The poppy displayed at the station for Remembrance Day / Armistice day, it is commemorated every year on 11th November. (Photo by Vuk Valcic / SOPA Images/Sipa USA)
Britain's Prime Minister Boris Johnson, and Chancellor Rishi Sunak during a visit to a distribution centre in London, Wednesday, Nov. 11, 2020. (AP Photo/Kirsty Wigglesworth, pool)
Pro EU supporters argue with Brexit supporters in London, Wednesday, Nov. 11, 2020. Negotiations continue on London between the EU bloc and British officials to agree A Brexit deal as Britain is due to split from Europe from January 1. (AP Photo/Frank Augstein)
The Cenotaph in London's Whitehall is being surrounded by wreathes of poppies laid there by the royal family and others in honour of Remembrance Day. (Photo by Brett Cove / SOPA Images/Sipa USA)
Jockey Paul O'Brien is unseated by Nightline in the Ten To Follow Conditional Jockeys' Veterans' Handicap Chase (Series Qualifier) at Huntingdon Racecourse.
A huge construction machine at Dawlish train station where work has begun building a new and bigger sea wall to protect the railway and town from rising sea levels using an eight-legged, self-contained walking jack-up barge, known as a Wavewalker � the only one of its kind in Europe. It is the first time this type of barge has been used to maintain the UK rail network and the machine is able to operate across high tidal ranges, which particularly impact the south Devon coastline.
Cruise boats seen moored on the River Thames next to Lambeth Palace. The River Thames has seen a huge reduction in traffic due to the ongoing pandemic. (Photo by Dave Rushen / SOPA Images/Sipa USA)
A general view of a Christmas decoration that says '2020 The Year of Lockdown', as the UK heads into the festive period in lockdown due to the coronavirus pandemic.
Shoppers queue to enter shops in Cardiff, Wales, Monday Nov. 9, 2020, after restrictions imposed by the Welsh government are relaxed following a two-week lockdown across Wales. (Ben Birchall/PA via AP)
People wearing face masks walking in the Covent Garden Market. Most shops, restaurants and businesses have closed as the second month-long nationwide Covid 19 lockdown begins in England. (Photo by Vuk Valcic / SOPA Images/Sipa USA)
A woman passes a Virginia Creeper displaying autumnal colours, on the walls of the Old Admiralty Building, in London, Monday Nov, 9, 2020. (Dominic Lipinski/PA via AP)
Members of the military use Anfield stadium as part of the mass testing taking place in the city of Liverpool, as a pilot for mass testing in the city enters its second week. (Photo by Peter Byrne/PA Images via Getty Images)
The Forth Bridge is covered by fog in the Firth of Forth, South Queensferry. (Photo by Jane Barlow/PA Images via Getty Images)
Anti-Brexit protester Steve Bray holds placards outside the Conference Centre in London, Monday, Nov. 9, 2020, as the European Commission's Head of Task Force for Relations with the United Kingdom Michel Barnier takes part in Brexit talks inside. With less than two months to go before the U.K. exits the EU's economic orbit, trade deal talks resume in London on Monday. (AP Photo/Matt Dunham)
Britain's Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster, Michael Gove is surrounded by photographers as he gets in a car in London, Monday, Nov. 9, 2020. (AP Photo/Frank Augstein)
Police officers arrest a protester during the demonstration. Protests all across the country have been seen this weekend challenging the latest lockdown that was imposed on the country earlier in the week. (Photo by Kenny Brown / SOPA Images/Sipa USA)
Veteran Charlie MacVicar, who served for 23 years with Royal Scots (Edinburgh Unit) pays his respects at the Royal British Legion Remembrance Garden, on Remembrance Sunday, in Grangemouth, Scotland, Sunday, Nov. 8, 2020. (Jane Barlow/PA via AP)
Britain's Queen Elizabeth II looks on from the balcony of the Foreign Office, during the Remembrance Sunday service at the Cenotaph, in Whitehall, London, Sunday Nov. 8, 2020. (Chris Jackson/Pool Photo via AP)
Seymour 'Bill' Taylor, 95, from Colchester, who served as an Able Seaman in the Royal Navy onboard HMS Emerald during the D-Day landings joins neighbours in the street to observe the two minutes silence to pay his respects on Remembrance Sunday, in Essex, England, Sunday, Nov. 8, 2020. (Joe Giddens/PA via AP)
Liverpool's manager Jurgen Klopp, left, and Manchester City's head coach Pep Guardiola greet each other at the end of the English Premier League soccer match between Manchester City and Liverpool at the Etihad stadium in Manchester, England, Sunday, Nov. 8, 2020. The game ended in a 1-1 draw. (Martin Rickett/Pool via AP)
EU chief negotiator Michel Barnier wearing a mask because of the novel coronavirus pandemic arrives at St Pancras Station in London on November 8, 2020 as work continues on a trade deal between the EU and the UK. - The European Union and Britain said on November 7 major divergences remain but that post-Brexit negotiations would continue next week to clinch a trade deal in the scant time left. (Photo by JUSTIN TALLIS / AFP) (Photo by JUSTIN TALLIS/AFP via Getty Images)

Rebecca Hilsenrath, chief executive of the commission, said women "suffered" at the BBC because of the complaints process and there were a number of areas where the broadcaster was "at risk of unlawful pay discrimination".

She praised the "courage" of women who came forward, saying she hoped they could take "comfort" from the report recommendations to improve the way pay issues are dealt with.

The EHRC said it received "evidence that several employees had been signed off work due to the stress of the process".

It spoke of some complainants who had waited two years for an outcome, while one was passed between eight different people in 10 months after raising the initial complaint.

"These are real people having a really terrible time," Ms Hilsenrath said.

"If the processes have let you down, then you don't trust what's going on. We hope our recommendations will help build a better relationship with the women at the BBC."

The commission said its investigation had a different remit to that of an employment tribunal.

It said it was legitimate for the BBC to take into account "specific attributes" when deciding pay such as "the extent to which an individual... makes a difference to broadcast programmes."

In the cases the EHRC analysed, the BBC said many of its pay decisions related to "profile, experience, audience recognition, market power and flight risk" – the possibility of being poached by rivals.

Tim Davie, new Director General of the BBC
Tim Davie, director-general of the BBC, said the broadcaster will accept and implement the EHRC's recommendations (Andrew Milligan/PA)

The watchdog said that "those factors can lawfully be relied upon to justify pay differences" and it "accepted that the factors explained the pay differences between men and women in these cases".

However, it stressed the importance of establishing a "clear method" to evaluate "the weight of these factors objectively".

The BBC's new director-general Tim Davie said the broadcaster accepts the recommendations.

"We note that the commission has made no unlawful findings against the BBC and recognises that there have been significant improvements to BBC pay practices in recent years," he said.

"However, we have to work even harder to be best in class. Trust is vitally important and, as an organisation that serves the public, the BBC must continue to lead the way on pay transparency and fairness. We are committed to building a truly inclusive culture.

"We agree with the commission that we should continue to deliver on our reform programme which began in 2015. We accept every one of their recommendations and will implement them."

Mr Davie recently told MPs that there are 20 gender discrimination cases outstanding at the corporation.

The EHRC launched an investigation into equal pay at the BBC last year, two years after the broadcaster sparked controversy by publishing the salaries of its highest earners.

Whereas Chris Evans, the BBC's highest-paid male at the time, earned between £2.2 million and £2.25 million in 2016/2017, Claudia Winkleman, the highest-paid female, earned between £450,000 and £500,000.

Latest BBC figures on the broadcaster's best-paid stars make Zoe Ball the top-earning talent – while Gary Lineker took a pay cut.

Fiona Bruce, Vanessa Feltz and Lauren Laverne are also in the top 10.

Read Full Story Click here to comment