The abililty of the pilot of a plane which plunged into a bay near Sydney killing five Britons was “likely significantly degraded” by carbon monoxide exposure, investigators have found.
British businessman Richard Cousins, the chief executive of a FTSE 100 catering giant, died alongside his two sons, fiancee Emma Bowden and her 11-year-old daughter when a sightseeing trip on New Year’s Eve, 2017, ended in tragedy.
The de Havilland Canada DHC-2 Beaver, piloted by Canadian Gareth Morgan, who also died, plunged into water in Jerusalem Bay, 25 miles north of Sydney city centre.
The Australian Transport Safety Bureau (ATSB) released its final report on Friday under the heading: Hawkesbury floatplane accident highlights the insidious danger of CO exposure.
The bureau’s chief commissioner Greg Hood said: “The ATSB has worked closely with medical experts to determine the pilot would have almost certainly experienced affects such as confusion, visual disturbance and disorientation.
“Consequently, the investigation found that it was likely that this significantly degraded the pilot’s ability to safely operate the aircraft.”
A preliminary report from 2018 said the plane hit an area of water away from the expected and standard flight path, crashing in a near-vertical position.
Carbon monoxide exposure likely significantly degraded the ability of the pilot of a Beaver floatplane to safely operate the aircraft before it collided with water in Jerusalem Bay on the Hawkesbury north of Sydney in December 2017.
— ATSB (@atsbgovau) January 28, 2021
In July the bureau delivered an update which said blood tests indicated the pilot and two of the passengers had elevated levels of carbon monoxide.
The final report revealed cracks in the aircraft’s exhaust and holes in its firewall “very likely” allowed carbon monoxide the cabin.
“This investigation reinforces the importance of conducting a thorough inspection of piston-engine exhaust systems and the timely repair or replacement of deteriorated components,” Mr Hood said.
“In combination with maintaining the integrity of the firewall, this decreases the possibility of CO entering the cabin.”
The ATSB has released an update to its on-going investigation into the collision with water of a DHC-2 Beaver floatplane at Jerusalem Bay, on 31 Dec 2017, in which the pilot and five passengers lost their lives, and has issued two Safety Advisory Notices.https://t.co/OsA5XocwBRpic.twitter.com/SNNBak93OK
— ATSB (@atsbgovau) July 2, 2020
The report recommended the use of “attention attracting” carbon monoxide detectors.
“The ATSB strongly encourages operators and owners of piston-engine aircraft to install a CO detector with an active warning to alert pilots to the presence of elevated levels of CO in the cabin. Where one is not fitted, pilots are encouraged to carry a personal CO detector,” Mr Hood said.
The bureau said the investigation would have been aided if the aircraft had been fitted with an on-board recording device.
Mr Hood said ATSB was formally recommending that the International Civil Aviation Organisation and Australia’s Civil Aviation Safety Authority “consider mandating the fitment of lightweight recording devices to smaller passenger-carrying aircraft”.