Home Secretary Sajid Javid has told social media companies “enough is enough” after footage of the terrorist attack in Christchurch spread rapidly across the networks and around the world.
Reacting to a tweet from YouTube claiming the video-sharing service was working to remove the footage, he said: “You really need to do more @YouTube @Google @facebook @Twitter to stop violent extremism being promoted on your platforms. Take some ownership. Enough is enough”
— Sajid Javid (@sajidjavid) March 15, 2019
Shooter Brenton Tarrant livestreamed the murder of 49 people in two mosques in Christchurch, New Zealand, on Friday morning after posting links to a manifesto and images of the weapons on Twitter.
Labour’s shadow digital secretary Tom Watson said Google’s response was “not good enough” after YouTube “reviewed” a copy of the video before removing it from the site.
Damian Collins, the Tory chairman of the Digital, Culture, Media and Sport Select Committee, called for a review into how the footage was shared and “why more effective action wasn’t taken to remove them”.
And Downing Street said social media companies need to act “more quickly” to remove terrorist content.
It's very distressing that the terrorist attack in New Zealand was live streamed on social media & footage was available hours later. There must be a serious review of how these films were shared and why more effective action wasn't taken to remove them.https://t.co/lk9UYWhIp4
— Damian Collins (@DamianCollins) March 15, 2019
Facebook said it “quickly removed” the video, while YouTube said it was “working vigilantly to remove any violent footage”.
Mr Watson hit out at Google for not taking the video down from YouTube immediately.
He said: “Google have contacted me to explain that they posted the ‘inappropriate’ content warning on the NZ massacre footage while they ‘reviewed the video’ for YouTube.
“Not good enough. They should have just taken it down, then reviewed it.”
Mr Collins added that it was “very distressing” that the attack was live streamed on social media, and that “footage was available hours later”.
“There must be a serious review of how these films were shared and why more effective action wasn’t taken to remove them,” he added.
Police are aware there is extremely distressing footage relating to the incident in Christchurch circulating online. We would strongly urge that the link not be shared. We are working to have any footage removed.
— New Zealand Police (@nzpolice) March 15, 2019
Before the shootings began, an anonymous user on messaging forum 8chan posted links to the manifesto and livestream, promising to “carry out an attack”.
8chan and the similar but unaffiliated site 4chan, where users are anonymous by default, have been the subject of controversy in recent years as some users praised US school shootings and far-right terrorist attacks, as well as sharing conspiracy theories, racist memes and images of child sexual abuse.
Mr Collins said: “These platforms are being used to disseminate the vilest content and make people aware of its existence.
“We should look at companies like that and say for them to allow their platforms to be used in that way is damaging to society. It’s hugely harmful.”
He called for a regulator to have the power to sanction companies allowing the spread of “harmful content”, adding that the “ultimate sanction” would be to bar them from the internet.
Google have contacted me to explain that they posted the "inappropriate" content warning on the NZ massacre footage while they "reviewed the video" for YouTube. Not good enough. They should have just taken it down, then reviewed it. pic.twitter.com/5Zh2IfxwgR
— Tom Watson (@tom_watson) March 15, 2019
Facebook New Zealand’s director of policy Mia Garlick said in a statement: “Our hearts go out to the victims, their families and the community affected by this horrendous act.
“New Zealand Police alerted us to a video on Facebook shortly after the livestream commenced and we quickly removed both the shooter’s Facebook and Instagram accounts and the video.
“We’re also removing any praise or support for the crime and the shooter or shooters as soon as we’re aware.
“We will continue working directly with New Zealand Police as their response and investigation continues.”
YouTube said on Twitter: “Our hearts are broken over today’s terrible tragedy in New Zealand.
“Please know we are working vigilantly to remove any violent footage.”
Our hearts are broken over today’s terrible tragedy in New Zealand. Please know we are working vigilantly to remove any violent footage.
— YouTube (@YouTube) March 15, 2019
A Twitter spokeswoman said: “We are deeply saddened by the shootings in Christchurch today.
“Twitter has rigorous processes and a dedicated team in place for managing exigent and emergency situations such as this.
“We also co-operate with law enforcement to facilitate their investigations as required.”
A Downing Street spokeswoman said: “They have taken action to take it down and we are clear that all companies need to act more quickly to remove terrorist content.
“There should be no safe spaces for terrorists to promote and share their extreme views.”