Caller exasperates James O'Brien by insisting the way to solve the Irish backstop's 'no border checks' issue is to have border checks

Today's James O'Brien show on LBC witnessed a very confident caller who claimed to have the solution to Irish backstop issue that has been thwarting progress in Brexit negotiations with the EU. However, things started to go downhill rather quickly when the host asked him to explain how it would work in practice.

The Prime Minister Theresa May is expected ask MPs to vote on her Brexit deal again on Tuesday and changes to the backstop will be key to winning that vote.

The EU approved withdrawal deal currently includes an agreement on the Irish border that demands no return of a "hard border" - physical checks or infrastructure - between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland after Brexit.

Within the agreement, the 'backstop' is a measure designed to ensure that this 'lack of 'hard border' continues after the UK leaves the EU. It only comes into effect if the deal deciding the future relationship between the UK and EU is not agreed by the end of the transition period (31 December 2020). Until the deal on the future relationship is done, the backstop would also keep the UK effectively inside the EU's customs union but with Northern Ireland also conforming to some rules of the single market. Critics say a different status for Northern Ireland could threaten the existence of the UK.

Therefore, when caller Alan suggested there was a solution to this thorny issue before March 29th, James asked how, when there is the requirement for no border checks on the Northern Irish border.

Challenged with the example of transporting chickens across a border where two different regulatory frameworks will exist either side, Alan responded by saying the authorities could do a "slowing down border where you pull over one in 100 lorries".

James went on to point out: "The whole requirement is no border checks. So you can't say I can solve the requirement of no border checks by having border checks.

Alan insisted he thought that was a great solution, so James continued: "But you've literally just said the way we would deal with the requirement that there be no border checks is by having border checks."

James O'Brien through the years
See Gallery
James O'Brien through the years
James O'Brien talking to caller
Mayor of London Sadiq Khan (right) hosts the first of his new monthly phone-ins on LBC, with James O'Brien at the Global Radio studios in London.
James O'Brien answers the phone during Global's Make Some Noise, radio's biggest ever charity appeal, at Global, Leicester Square, London.
Ricky Gervais meets LBC's James O'Brien at Global Radio in London.
James O'Brien at Global's Make Some Noise Appeal Day, set up by Global, to raise money to help disadvantaged children, young people and their families across the UK
David Lawley-Wakelin joins LBC presenter James O'Brien regarding his interruption to Tony Blair at the Leveson Inquiry yesterday. Global Radio in Leicester Square, central London.
Russell Brand with James O'Brien after he joined the radio presenter on his show 'James O'Brien Live on LBC' at the London radio station.
Archbishop of Canterbury Justin Welby (right) joins LBC presenter James O'Brien (left) to host his first live radio phone-in at their studios in central London.
LONDON, ENGLAND - NOVEMBER 20: James O'Brien attends the Love Island final viewing party hosted by Capital for Global’s Make Some Noise charity at the Ham Yard Hotel on November 20, 2018 in London, England. (Photo by Tristan Fewings/Getty Images)
Jamie Theakston and James O'Brien at Global's Make Some Noise Night in Finsbury Square, London. The gala raised money for the national charity Global's Make Some Noise, set up by Global to help disadvantaged children, young people and their families across the UK.
LONDON, ENGLAND - MARCH 17: James O'Brien attends the Broadcasting Press Guild Television & Radio Awards at Theatre Royal on March 17, 2017 in London, England. (Photo by Tim P. Whitby/Getty Images)
James O'Brien on stage at Global's Make Some Noise Night at Supernova, Victoria Embankment Gardens, London. The star-studded event raised money for Global's Make Some Noise, the charity set up by Global, the media and entertainment group, to help disadvantaged youngsters across the UK. PRESS ASSOCIATION Photo. Picture date: Thursday November 23, 2017. Photo credit should read: Ian West/PA Wire
Prime Minister Gordon Brown in the studio with LBC presenter James O'Brien during his visit to open the Headquarters of Global Radio in Leicester Square, central London.
Diver Tom Daley is pictured with James O'Brien on LBC 97.3 where he has been talking about his career and Nestle's Get Set, Go Free campaign, which gives families the opportunity to try activities for free this summer.

He later added: "I will never understand how anybody with a functioning cerebral cortex can say the way to solve the way to solve the problem of not having any border checks is to have border checks. Let alone on national radio."

Read Full Story