Jack Wills wins logo court action

2013 Holiday Shopping Windows - Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

%VIRTUAL-SkimlinksPromo%Clothing brand Jack Wills has won its High Court action against House of Fraser over its logo of a silhouette of a pheasant with a top hat and cane.

The company claimed that the department store's use, between November 2011 and February 2013, of a logo consisting of the silhouette of a pigeon with a top hat and bow-tie constituted trade mark infringement.
Its counsel, Roger Wyand QC, said that the similarity of the "Mr Wills" logo, which is used in three different versions with the simplest registered as both a UK and a Community trade mark, and the pigeon logo, which appears in two slightly different versions on a selection of the store's own Linea range of men's clothing, was likely to cause confusion among customers.

At London's High Court today, Mr Justice Arnold said that there was a likelihood of confusion on the part of the average consumer.

"As counsel for Jack Wills pointed out, the human eye has a tendency to see what it expects to see."

Even assuming that the consumer appreciated that the two logos were different, there was an obvious resemblance between them, in particular the conceptual similarity.

He said that House of Fraser intended the pigeon logo to have brand significance and that was how consumers would have perceived it.

"Furthermore, it is clear that House of Fraser's intention in using the pigeon logo was to make the garments more attractive to consumers.

"I consider that it was a classic case of a retailer seeking to enhance the attraction of its own brand goods by adopting an aspect of the get-up of prestigious branded goods, in this case an embroidered logo of the kind used by Fred Perry, Lacoste, Polo Ralph Lauren and others.

"Thus House of Fraser was seeking to influence the economic behaviour of consumers of Linea menswear. I see no reason to think it will not have succeeded in that endeavour."

He added that he considered it a legitimate inference from the nature of the particular market and the logos that, due to its resemblance to the trade marks, the effect of House of Fraser's use of the pigeon logo would have been to cause a subtle but insidious transfer of image from the trade marks to the pigeon logo - and hence from Jack Wills' goods to House of Fraser's goods - in the minds of some consumers, whether that was House of Fraser's intention or not.

"This will have assisted House of Fraser to increase the attraction of its goods in circumstances where House of Fraser did not undertake any advertising or promotion of those goods. Furthermore, House of Fraser had no justification for such conduct.

"Thus I conclude that House of Fraser did take unfair advantage of the reputation of the trade marks."

Find the hidden meanings in logos
See Gallery
Jack Wills wins logo court action

According to webdesignerdepot, the arrow under the word Amazon from the A-Z has two purposes. First, it is meant to highlight that the company sells everything from A-Z, and second it's a smile - meant to emphasise a focus on customer satisfaction.

The same website highlights that if you focus hard on the logo you can see a white arrow between the E and the x, emphasising speed and precision. It's this which won the logo - designed in 1994 - a vast number of awards.

The F is clearly written in black, but the 1 emerges out of the white space between the F and the red lines representing speed. For every person who says 'yes but that's hardly hidden is it?' there's someone saying 'oh... yes...'

According to the company the white ribbon was introduced under the name in 1969. When competitors first entered the market, Coke made much of its curved bottle design which distinguished it from those that followed. As fewer and fewer people drank from bottles, the ribbon was produced as an alternative distinctive curve.

On the left hand side of the packaging is a picture of the Matterhorn mountain. However, if you look closer there's the image of a bear lurking within - to show that the company is based in Bern - known as The City of Bears.

According to mokokoma, the apple is the fruit of the tree of knowledge. There is some question as to whether the bite taken out of it is a play on the word byte, symbolism of the fruit being eaten and the knowledge imparted, or just to make it look more like an apple and less like a cherry tomato.

According to urlm, the reason for the odd V and A is because it's a wave - symbolising the basic analogue signal, while the I and O look like a 1 and a 0, representing digital.

The same website highlights the reason behind the Roxy logo - a brand for female surfers. The brand is actually part of Quicksilver, and is made up of two Quicksilver logos pushed together to form a heart.

As graphicdesignblog points out, this isn't just white text on a series of coloured blobs. Each blob represents the outline of London at a specific time - and shows the growth of the city through history.

The letters are made of one unbroken line - as if drawn in the air with a conductor's baton.

The portions of the B and R coloured pink aren't just an accident. They form the number 31 - the number of flavours sold by the brand.

As pointed out by studentbeans.com, if you look more closely at the letters o,u and r, and put them together with the sun, they form a cyclist.

Why the extra-large C? Because the way it wraps around the o creates a 3D tyre of course.

One blogger has been researching the origins of car logos. He highlights that the wings on the car logo are designed to reflect the company's past as an aircraft engine manufacturer during WWI.

This is another wartime company reflecting its past. The colours are the Bavarian flag, representing the company's origins, and the cross inside the circle represents a propeller - harking back to the company's past making aeroplanes during WWII.

Apparently the diamond was an integral part of the design of the early cars - which was fitted around an air hole in the bonnet.

If you look closely you can see the map is showing Apple's address - complete with a pin dropped at its front door.

The arrows pointing in each direction reflect that the name means Crossroads. If you look a bit closer, the C looms out of the white space.

The logo was actually designed by professor Vaughan Pratt of Stanford University. It is an ambigram - which takes advantage of the fact that a U and an N sitting next to one another can be made to look like an S, and therefore read 'sun' in every direction.

According to funonthenet those three stripes are actually in the shape of a mountain, signifying the challenges ahead, and the goals you can achieve.

Read Full Story