Would you pay £280 for a £250 gift card?

Gift card

Starbucks has sold what can only be described as the weirdest gift card on the high street this year. With the Starbucks Gilt Card, the company took the unusual step of charging more for the card than you got in credit, so to charge it up with £250 cost £280.

Surely you'd be crazy to get one... so why did they sell out seconds after going on sale?
According to the Daily Telegraph, the cards actually went on sale in the US, through a website called Gilt.com. They cost $450 - which is roughly £280 - and they were charged with $400 credit (£250).

Far from being a laughing stock, the website said they sold out in 6 seconds. Some buyers even went to Twitter to complain that they hadn't managed to get hold of a card

So what's the attraction?

NBC News reported that the reason for the extra $50 cost of the card is that the card itself costs $50 to produce. So in that sense you're not overpaying for the credit - you're buying very expensive metal card.

It also comes with 'gold level' status (which you're normally entitled to free in the US when you buy 15 coffees a year). It means you get a free treat on your birthday, special offers and a free drink every 15 purchases. However, this alone is clearly not worth $50.

The real attraction is that in a country where one in ten people get a coffee card for Christmas, these are considered desirable and collectible. There are a host of special edition Starbucks cards available at different times of year and from different locations, and there are avid collectors.

These cards were 'rose-coloured' gold and just 1,000 were made, so they are a show-stopper in any collection.

It may sound fanciful, but with one hour to go, today a card was up for sale on eBay and reached $900. Another had three hours to go and reached $820, and a third reached $800 with six hours left to bid.

Worse value

Although this looks like an odd choice, and the worst-value card on the high street, it could prove an interesting investment for those who got their hands on a card.

In fact, oddly, they could turn out to be one of the best value gift cards to give. Traditional gift cards remain inexplicably popular. We are not being put off by the fact that so many high street names went under last year. We're not worried that when a firm is in administration they are not obliged to accept the cards - so they could ultimately prove worthless. So a survey by the UKGCVA found that 50% of people intend to give a gift card this Christmas - spending an estimated £2 billion.

Not only is there the risk they could prove worthless, there's also the very real risk that they end up languishing in our wallets and they never get spent. Gocompare research found that 44% of us have gift cards and vouchers gathering dust, and one in four of us have £80 or more worth of cards lying around. Meanwhile 16% of us have left them so long that they have expired - and ended up worth nothing.

It begs the question as to whether you should give the cards a miss altogether and hand over cash instead. A survey by Azimo found that 53% of people named cash as their favourite gift of all. It seems that it's not the thought that counts after-all.

But what do you think? Would you invest in a 'collectors' card, would you value a gift card, or would you rather have the cash?

10 luxury Christmas gift ideas for him and her
See Gallery
Would you pay £280 for a £250 gift card?
At ten times the price of the latest iPhone, a phone needs to be a bit special - and this one is. British company Vertu's Ti Android smartphone is based on a dual core 1.7GHz processor, with 1GB RAM and 64GB of internal memory, and features a sapphire crystal screen for clarity and durability. But it's the services that really make this phone stand out from the crowd: the Ti features a Concierge button that contacts a team of people who will fulfil your every whim - whether that's a restaurant booking or a team of bodyguards. It costs around £6,700.
At £1,250, the Aspinal Portofino Rolling Cabin Bag costs more than most holidays but will look beautiful pretty much for ever. Handmade from calf skin leather, it rests on heavy-duty brass feet and features a lockable shoe compartment. If it's packed too full to use the leather shoulder strap, a telescopic handle emerges like magic to let you wheel it along. Rather wonderfully, it comes in a bag of its own to protect it from scuffs and scratches in the aircraft hold.
Football scarves don't have to be made of acrylic and emblazoned with advertising logos. If your other half would appreciate a rather more stylish version, it's worth checking out Savile Rogue. The company's cashmere versions boast simply the club's colours, and are wonderfully cosy and soft. They have beanie hats and other accessories too. Scarves cost £58.95.
If you've really got cash to flash, there can be few men that would turn up their noses at McClaren's new MP4-12C Spider - Top Gear's 'Car of the Year'. If you've got a spare £225,0000 lying about, that's the other half sorted there and then. But if not, how about buying him a day's rental? At £825 from www.hertzsupercars.com, it's a bargain.
The Japanese are whisky connoisseurs, and it's perhaps no surprise that the first distiller to make whisky in the country, Suntory Whisky, won Distiller of the Year for the third time at this year's International Spirits Challenge. Early next month, Harrods will take delivery of 50 bottles of Yamazaki 25 Year Old Whisky - and one can be yours, or your lucky partner's, for just £1,400.
Whole hives of bees seem to be buzzing around jewellery departments at the moment, but Theo Fennell's version is a bit special. Handmade from 18 carat yellow gold and diamonds, this drop pendant boasts a 25.15 carat Zambian emerald, topped by a 1.04 carat diamond. It costs £65,000.
Silk isn't just glamorous, it's surprisingly warm too. But it's the looks of this beautiful gown from silk specialists Vivis that will appeal. The Dalila Anthracite Gown comes in a beautiful dark grey and costs £288 from the Pyjama Store - perfect for those long winter nights.
It's a food hamper - but what a hamper! Carluccio's Italia includes a whole roasted ham, Salame La Gabbianella, white truffle oil, fresh black truffle, Amarena Fabbri cherries, venison ragu and a selection of Planeta wines. But there's more: an olive plant, a signed copy of Antonio Carluccio's Passion for Pasta cookbook and an Imperia Italian pasta machine. It costs £600, from www.carluccios.com.
New from British designer Justin Wolter, this smartphone dock is a piece of sculpture in its own right. The Gramohorn II works only with the HTC One phone - so you may need to buy one of those as well. Produced using high-tech 3D printing, it channels music naturally through its huge gramophone-like chambers, so doesn't need any power source. It's hand finished in any colour, and costs £999 in a plaster resin build, or £4,999 in milled stainless steel from from www.gramohorn.com.
Laura Orchant is known for her scarves' stunning patterns and jewel-like colours. Laura first hand-draws her images, and then digitally manipulates them into an explosion of bright colours and fractal patterns. The Leaf scarf in pink, available from Fenwicks and Laura's own website, is a particular beauty; prices start at £100.

Read Full Story