'Callous' Tesco tweet criticised by MP

Robert Halfon

Robert Halfon, MP for Harlow (pictured), has criticised a Tweet by Tesco distribution director Steve Strachota, in which he praised his team for 'awesome teamwork' in shutting five depots down. The MP told the BBC that the tweets had been forwarded to him by constituents, and seemed to celebrate the depot's closure.

So what happened, and what does this tell us about the dangers of Twitter?


Tesco is changing the way its distribution centres work, and as a result it is closing depots in Harlow, Barlborough and Weybridge. It is also relocating sites in Daventry and Middlewich to Milton Keynes - and opening new distribution centres in Dagenham and Reading.

Strachota has been closely involved in the changes, managing the process as well as dealing with staff who are losing their jobs and those who are relocating. He took to Twitter to congratulate those who were involved in the seamless transfer from five depots to three, but his remarks upset some people.

According to the Daily Mail the Tweet said: "5 depots closing and 3 new ones ready to go. Awesome teamwork, courageous leadership, a bit of luck ‪#‬world class."

Halfon said he had been disturbed by the message. He wrote to Tesco saying: "It seems to me that, given what has happened in Harlow, and the upset it caused to many people, your senior managers appear to be wallowing in what they have done. I find it very sad that a company that I have had huge respect for seems to be so callous in their treatment of workers, many of whom have given over 20 years of service to Tesco."

He has also tabled a motion in the House of Commons to voice disappointment about the issue.

Tesco said in a statement: "This tweet was intended to acknowledge that difficult decisions had been taken in order to make significant changes to our distribution network. Steve has spoken to our colleagues at Harlow in person to explain this and they recognised that it should be seen in that context. Nonetheless, we sincerely apologise if the tweet caused any offence, and it has now been removed."

So is the criticism fair?

The social networks are abuzz with criticism of Strachota. Robert C tweeted: "I will avoid shopping in ‪#tesco‬ for a year. Awesome teamwork on my part. ‪#worldclass‬ steve strachota, you deserve to loose your job." Mark Bardney added: "‪@UKTesco‬ Will Steve Strachota now be shown the door? What a disgraceful representative for your company." GW agreed: "‪@UKTesco‬ steve strachota should resign. If he thinks losing thousands of jobs is awesome then he is a sad man".

Clearly he has made a mistake, but when you consider the job he's doing, it becomes clear why he made it.

The process of closing the distribution centres and opening the new ones - without disrupting supply - is a massive logistical undertaking, requiring dedication from his own team. Strachota has made every effort to praise and motivate his team through Twitter in the last few months. He tweeted on 2 May: "Gr8 day with distribution leadership. No other team in the world I would chose to face this year's challenges!" On 10 May he said: "What a week! I am surrounded by great people involved in everyday heroics. ‪#bestinclass‬"

There are few who would argue with the importance of showing people some appreciation for the job they have done, and the controversial tweet was intended to do just that.

The problem was that on Twitter you cannot choose your audience. If you're going to thank your team for doing a great job (which happened to involve hundreds of people losing their jobs) - it's best not to do it in a place where all those who have been fired can read it. The aim may have been motivational, but you can see how it backfired.

It's one of the risks of Twitter. If you want to say something, you need to be aware you are saying it to anyone who cares to look. And if you make a mistake there's always the risk it will be re-tweeted far beyond the audience who may ever stumble on it on your account.

Strachota may well be wondering why he chose Twitter for his motivational tool - rather than speaking to his team in person, or sending them a carefully-worded email.

It's yet another reason why we all need to think before we tweet.

Top 10 expensive celebrity mistakes
See Gallery
'Callous' Tesco tweet criticised by MP

The N-Dubz singer was allegedly caught fixing up a drug deal between an undercover Sun reporter and her dealer friend and part-time rapper Mike GLC.

The illegal activity is likely to cost Tulisa dearly as she has cashed in on her youth appeal through the story of her troubled background and claims to have shunned drugs to grow her music career.

The modern day sporting hero and winner of seven consecutive Tour de France competitions saw his reputation plummet last year when he was found guilty of doping and cheating his way through is career.

Armstrong was stripped of all his titles, ordered to return his prize money, and sponsors couldn't drop him quick enough. He is also being sued by teammates. It is estimated that it will cost him $125m.

After possibly one of biggest public meltdowns in history, the actor lost it with the creator of his TV series Two and a Half Men. His outburst together with outlandish behavior including alleged drug benders, porn stars and drink problems, lead to Sheen being fired from the show. He reportedly earned $1.25m per episode, meaning he lost $36m for the whole season.

At the height of her short career, teen star Lohan was commanding around $7.5m per movie at four movies per year. Yet the pressures of fame at a young age got to The Parent Trap and Mean Girls star, seeing her life spiral out of control as she became embroiled in allegations of drug and alcohol abuse, jewellery theft, and drunk driving. Her earnings quickly plummeted and remain he doldrums.

Singer Chris Brown's reputation became muddied in 2009 amid allegations of assault against his then girlfriend, pop diva Rhianna.

The alleged offense took place the night before both stars were set to perform at the 2009 Grammy Awards. Brown's arrest on felony charges and the brutal images of Rhianna's battered face, led to an huge media frenzy. Overnight, Brown went from whiter-than-white Wrigley's gum and milk spokesperson to the most loathed man in music.

Fashions favourite supermodel could do no wrong until she appeared in the Daily Mirror in 2005 snorting "line after line" of cocaine at a recording studio with then-boyfriend and known drug addict, Pete Doherty.

Dubbed 'Cocaine Kate' by the press, Chanel promptly dropped Moss from their advertising, as did fashion house Burberry and Swedish brand H&M. But Moss managed to recover quickly from the scandal and is now the face of Rimmel, Dior and Mango.

Infidelity cost the golf star more than his marriage and a staggering $100 million divorce settlement – shaving brand Gillette was one of many brands to pull its endorsements following the incident in 2009. Woods also lost deals with Gatorade, AT&T and Accenture following the scandal.

Photos of the Olympic swimmer smoking a marijuana pipe saw Kellogg's pull its sponsorship of the sports star to protect their brand images. Phelps also received a suspension from competition and USA Swimming pulled financial support for three months.

Brazilian footballer Ronaldinho was axed from his Coca-Cola sponsorship deal after appearing with a can of Pepsi during a press conference at Atletico Minerio. The mistake cost the star £1 million in unpaid earnings as his £500,000 per-year contract was set to run until 2014.

While serving as president, Bill Clinton became embroiled in an embarrassing high profile scandal that looked set to cost him his career. The former president was accused of having sexual relations with intern Monica Lewinsky and harassment charges against Paula Jones.

Clinton was acquitted of perjury and obstruction of justice charges and made a public apology, which only served to strengthen his reputation. He went on to serve two presidency terms and left the office with the highest end-of-office approval rating of any U.S. president since World War II.


More stories
Read Full Story