Are Michael Gove's advisers avoiding tax?

Michael Gove

Kevin Brennan, the shadow schools minister, has written to Michael Gove, the Education Secretary, asking for clarification about the payment of his 'academy brokers'. It emerged yesterday that they were being paid as personal service companies rather than being employed by the government.

But why is this happening, and are taxpayers being ripped off?


There are 24 Academy Brokers, who work to encourage state schools to apply to be academies. Brennan started asking questions yesterday in parliament, and Gove's answers revealed that instead of being employed by the civil service, they are paid off-the-books.

Gove's office told The Daily Telegraph that they did this in order to ensure that the advisers could be used flexibly and effectively. They explained that these were experts - including former head teachers and Ofsted Inspectors - who could not be sourced from within the Civil Service. They also emphasised that it was an arrangement set up when Labour was in power, and that Gove's office had actually negotiated lower rates.

Not cheap

However, it's not cheap. Some individuals are paid up to £1,000 a day for their services. It's also a great way for the individuals in question to pay less tax: they are able to pay corporation tax at 20% rather than income tax at anything up to 45%.

There's nothing illegal about these arrangements, but the government has spoken out against using this sort of pay arrangement in the civil service, claiming they are depriving the Treasury of essential funds.

It's unfortunate that this news should break on the day that David Cameron took his anti-avoidance message to the EU, complaining that the losses from 'aggressive avoidance' were 'staggering'.

He said: "In a period of fiscal consolidation where hard-working citizens and businesses are being asked to bear extra burdens, we need co-ordinated, truly global action to address these issues."

It seems that his government could do with a similar slice of co-ordination.

At the same time, there's the question of whether at these sorts of rates it can really be more cost-effective to employ these people as freelancers. Given that the Public Accounts Committee attacked the Academies project for overspending this week, these revelations are coming at an embarrassing time.

Asking questions

Now Brennan has another raft of questions, which could also prove difficult for Gove. He asks: "What steps has the department taken to ensure academy brokers are paying the correct tax? How many of them are former civil servants? How many academy brokers are there in total, how many are on payroll and how many are off?"

The pressure is now on for Gove to investigate the individual tax affairs of his advisers, and discover whether they are taking payment from the government, and paying as little of it back as possible.

The question is whether he will go this far? Is it any of his business? What do you think? let us know in the comments.

Ten most hated professions in the UK
See Gallery
Are Michael Gove's advisers avoiding tax?

They might think they're masters of the universe. We know they've dobbed the rest of us in it. After lending out recklessly, they are blamed for causing the financial crisis. Even after they had to be bailed out by taxpayers, they still give themselves obscene bonuses.

Have the power to enter your home and seize your possessions. Debt collectors are a form of bailiff-lite. They can 'only' write, phone or visit your home to talk about the debt. Don't bother bringing out the best china.

Last year's heavy snow meant lost parking revenue, as attendants were stopped from handing out as many tickets as normal. Edinburgh Council lost more than £700k in parking revenue in just two weeks. Expect parking wardens to redouble their efforts as they make up for that in the rest of 2011.

Yes, there are honourable exceptions. There are also reasons why these guys have the reputation they do.

Not as venal as some on the list. But some of these guys would persuade their granny to sell for £50,000 less than her home is really worth. Just so they can get a deal done and take their commission. It's always one story with them when you're selling. Another when you're buying.

Not independent, despite what they claim. Until big changes in the law come into effect in the next couple of years, they are paid on commission. So it's in their interest to stuff clients into whichever products pay them the most - it doesn't matter whether the product is any good or not.

These guys will charge you for yawning. But there's no fighting them. They set up the system and know best how to work it.  The ultimate parasites? But then, they earn so much money what do they care what other people think?

It's 6.30pm, the hour when hell gates open for every parent. The phone rings. It turns out to be a gentleman from Bangladesh, selling you phones in indescribably bad English.

Low barriers to entry mean spamming is on the rise. Experts expect 7 trillion spam messages to be sent this year, costing millions in lost productivity and fraud. Internet service providers are among those worst affected. They have been forced to add extra capacity to carry the messages.

An out-of-place figure on your tax return, or big fluctuation from year to year could be enough to prompt a dreaded tax inspection. Since 2009 HM Revenue and Customers have been able to check a wider range of payments than before. Previously they could only look at VAT and employer returns. Now they have the power to inspect income tax, capital gains, PAYE and corporation tax


More stories
Read Full Story