Jamie Oliver sued for calling beef product 'pink slime'

Jamie OliverRobert Schlesinger/DPA/Press Association Images

Jamie Oliver's US TV programme on school dinners was controversial for a number of reasons. Now it is gaining attention for its use of the word 'pink slime' to describe a meat product known in the trade as 'lean, finely textured beef'. A former employee of a manufacturer of the product is suing him, and a number of other people in the media, claiming it eventually led to him losing his job.

So what is he claiming?

The product

Lean finely textured beef was something Oliver drew attention to in the UK in his school dinners series here. He attempted to recreate it with children in an effort to shock them into re-thinking their fondness for processed foods such as hamburgers.

The product is made from beef (after all the muscular joints of meat have been removed), which is heated and spun in a large drum to force the meat away from the fat, it is then treated to kill any bacteria and shaped ready for sale.


According to the BBC, Bruce Smith, 58, was one of roughly 750 people fired by Beef Products Inc, which makes lean, finely textured beef, after it closed three plants and downsized its South Dakota office. He lost his job there as senior counsel and director of Environmental, Health and Safety

He is now suing Jamie Oliver, along with food blogger Bettina Siegel, ABC News - its journalists Diane Sawyer and Jim Avila and 10 other unnamed defendants.

Smith claims that the phrase 'pink slime' and the campaign against it led to him losing his job. According to the BBC he wants £43,000 in damages - which he says were caused by the use of the 'unfair' phrase.

The claims

He said in a statement that the firm and "its employees were unfairly and unnecessarily maligned and accused of producing a food product that did not exist, a product that critics unfairly labelled 'pink slime'.

He added: "Defendant Oliver proceeded to use his celebrity chef media notoriety to place pressure on American fast food company McDonald's, and others, to immediately stop using (lean finely textured beef) LFTB ground beef in its retail menu food products."

The LA Times says that as a result of the campaign, schools, supermarkets and restaurants including McDonalds stopped using the product.

According to the BBC, ABC News and Oliver made no comment on the law suit. Siegel said in a blog post: "I'm confident the First Amendment protects the rights of all Americans, including bloggers like myself, against meritless attempts at censorship like this one. I will vigorously defend my right, and the rights of all of us, to speak out on matters of public importance."

There are those who argue that these individuals did not coin the term 'pink slime'. It was first used in a report in the New York Times in 2009 - long before Oliver's programme - after being coined by a US Scientist.

Separately, in September, Beef Products filed a defamation lawsuit against ABC News, alleging that the network misled Americans about the safety of its meat. It is claiming $1.2 billion in damages.

Smith has also written a book called "Pink Slime Ate My Job", which is raising money for those hit by the layoffs.

10 of the weirdest celebrity products
See Gallery
Jamie Oliver sued for calling beef product 'pink slime'

When it comes to bizarre celebrity products, they don't come much weirder than the Bill Wyman Signature Metal Detector, designed and marketed by the former Rolling Stones bass guitarist.

Apparently, Wyman, who is now in his mid-70s, loves archaeology and has used his own metal detector to find relics in the English countryside dating back to the Roman Empire.

Fans of US president Barack Obama can show their appreciation for the politician by buying a Barack Obama Chia - shaped like the president's head - and growing grass out of the top of it.

And for those who prefer a more historical theme to their garden ornaments, Chias shaped like the heads of George Washington and Abraham Lincoln are also available.

Action star Sylvester Stallone put out a protein-infused pudding designed to appeal to fans keen to build muscles like the big man's.

Unfortunately for them, however, the pudding has now been taken off the market.

Heiress Paris Hilton endorses numerous products, ranging from outfits for your dog to hair extensions.

But the most random Paris Hilton product on the market has to be her line of craft supplies, the Creativity Collection, which features items such as stickers and transfers.

Rapper Snoop Dogg's latest business venture is a "smokeable" lyric book.

"Rolling Words: A Smokable Songbook" contains the words to some of Snoop's biggest hits, including "Ain't Nothing But A G'Thang" and "Gin and Juice" - all on cigarette rolling papers.

Hollywood film director David Lynch loves coffee so, of course, he decided to make his own.

Embarrassingly, the tagline on the David Lynch Signature Cup is "It's all in the beans ... and I'm just full of beans."

Former boxer George Foreman's grill is undoubtedly the most successful, random celebrity product of recent years.

The "machine", which claims to reduce the fat content of your meal by 42%, has earned Foreman more than $200 million over the last decade or so.

Supermodel Heidi Klum has her own line of low-fat sweets, which includes Heidi's Yogurt Dessert Cremes and Heidi's Yogurt Fruit Cremes.

Apparently, the design of the sweets is influenced by icons that Klum uses in her text messages to friends. Strange.

Actor Danny DeVito is such a big fan of Italian liquer Limoncello, he decided to launch one of his own.

Called Danny DeVito's Premium Limoncello, the diminutive star claims that it's "like pouring yourself a glass of liquid sunshine straight from Italy's Sorrentine Peninsula".

Steven Seagal made his name leaping around in action films that allowed him to show off his martial arts prowess. But he is also behind an energy drink called Lightning Bolt.

Advertised as being "packed with vitamins and exotic botanicals", it sounds like just the tipple if you are planning to take on 10 armed men with your bare hands.


More stories

Read Full Story