BT 'misleading' adverts banned

BT TowerClive Gee/PA Archive/Press Association Images

The Advertising Standards Authority has banned an advertising campaign from BT after it claimed that its Infinity service was 'unbeatable'. Virgin Media and three others had questioned the veracity of the claims.

So what was BT saying, and where did it fall short?

The arguments

The adverts made a number of claims which rankled with Virgin Media and the other complainants. As well as saying that the speeds were 'unbeatable', it also claimed that the service was 'four times faster' without giving any context and 'three times faster' while not giving a clear explanation.

The 'unbeatable claim' appeared in all the adverts. BT argued that it wasn't claiming to be the fastest service. It highlighted that although other providers have a 10mbps service, none had one that was faster. It was therefore joint-best and as such was unbeatable.

Virgin pointed out that the adverts went on to list a number of things you could do online - including 'sharing' photos and videos. Virgin highlighted that you cannot download video or photos as fast with a BT service as you can with Virgin. BT argued that people who read the advert would read the word 'share' as meaning they could upload videos and photos at unbeatable speeds. The ASA sided with Virgin.

Virgin Media pointed out that superfast speeds were only available with certain packages and not to all Infinity customers, and the ASA agreed that making claims without explaining there were two available speeds was misleading.

BT defended its claims of being 'three times faster' because it is for some services. It also said the four times faster claim was based on Ofcom averages, and that clicking on the advert would take users to a page which explained this. The ASA said it wasn't clear from the adverts which services were faster, or what it was claiming to be four times faster than, so again said it was misleading.

BT cannot run the adverts as they are again

Top advertising icons that are no more
See Gallery
BT 'misleading' adverts banned

The lone cowboy quadrupled sales of Philip Morris' Marlboro cigarettes when he first appeared in the 1950s. Despite increasing evidence from mid-century scientists of health risks associated with smoking, Marlboro Man was influential in persuading the public to continue to light up.

Remember the little mascots for Robertson's jam? People sent away in their millions to the jam makers for golly brooches and other golly-related memorabilia. When Golly retired in 2002, the official reason was that children had lost interest in him. But many suspected the forces of political correctness were at play. Over 20m gollies were sent out by Robertson's in their heyday. Many have become valued collectors' items.

A boy and girl in ragged clothes catch the smell of Bisto gravy on the breeze and sigh longingly "Ahhh... Bisto." The advert, drawn by cartoonist Wilf Owen, first appeared in 1919. The gambit aimed to capture an 'Oliver Twist' quality, appealing to the 'urchin' segment of the working class market.

The yellow talking cartoon bird made his calls to advertise Post Office Telecommunications (now BT) perched on telephone wires. His catchphrase was "Make someone happy with a phone call". Bernard Cribbens provided the voice.

Beatrice Bellman was a popular character from a series of TV adverts by British Telecom, famously played by Maureen Lipman. She was a stereotypical Jewish mother and grandmother, with a heart of gold. Her adventures mostly involved nagging her long-suffering family over the phone. The name Beattie was a play on 'BT', as British Telecom later became known.

Any BP ad showing green fields and clean seas. Nowadays inappropriate for reasons too obvious to outline here.

Toilet paper makers Andrex have chosen to digitise their iconic puppy for the first time since the dog hit our screens in 1972. The series of more than 120 adverts featuring a live puppy made even something as utilitarian as toilet paper appear cute - no mean feat.

A blue floating shost-like creature with a long pointed nose, he featured in an educational animation programme created by Nick Spargo for British Gas in 1975. Willo's job was to extol the virtues of gas. Actor Kenneth Williams provided the voice. Willo later went on to great success in his own TV series, before retiring into obscurity.


No surprise

This is a shocking example, but it won't come as any surprise to consumers to hear that broadband adverts aren't quite what they may seem. In the past, advertisers have been able to boast about their fastest speeds without any mention of the reality for most users. It meant adverts all over the country for speeds of up to 20MB and 24MB when the average user gets just 7.5 MB. It's hardly surprising, therefore, that research found that 89% of people felt broadband advertising was misleading.

Since April 1, companies have only allowed to advertise speeds that are achievable by at least 10% of customers. However, Dominic Baliszewski, broadband expert says: "Setting the advertised maximum speed at a figure that only a privileged few customers can receive will still rub salt in the wound for the remaining 90% of customers who have little chance of achieving the provider's best speeds."

"Customers need to be empowered to make an informed choice. This means they need access to accurate information regarding broadband speeds from the first advert they see, to the point they make a purchase. We would like to see 'typical speeds' made the gold standard for broadband advertising in the same way that banks use typical APR percentages, giving consumers a much clearer picture of the kind of service they are likely to receive."

More stories

Read Full Story