GP shortages not to blame for high A&E attendances, new study claims

Long-term health conditions are driving increasing attendance at A&E departments rather than GP shortages, a new study has claimed.

Researchers at Queen Mary University of London examined the records of nearly 820,000 patients registered across 136 practices in east London to find the reasons behind rising demand on hospitals.

Social deprivation and suffering from numerous prolonged health problems were the main factors inflating emergency department attendance, it was found.

Patients with four or more long-term conditions had an attendance rate six times higher than those with no such complications.

Conditions included asthma, cancer, coronary heart disease, dementia and depression.

Social deprivation is also a key indicator for who is most likely to end up in A&E (Peter Byrne/PA)
Social deprivation is also a key indicator for who is most likely to end up in A&E (Peter Byrne/PA)

The study, published in the British Journal of General Practice, refutes claims that a lack of doctors' services were forcing patients to instead seek treatment in hospital.

Lead researcher Sally Hull said: "When departments are very busy, with long waits and difficulties finding beds for people needing admission, it is easy to seek scapegoats and suggest that poorly functioning GP services are to blame for the crisis.

She added: "The same people who attend their GP surgery a lot also attend their emergency department a lot.

"This is largely because they have multiple long term health conditions, both mental and physical, and it is these conditions, along with an ageing population, which are driving the high attendance rates."

A lack of GP services has previously been blamed for the spike (Lynne Cameron/PA)
A lack of GP services has previously been blamed for the spike (Lynne Cameron/PA)

Attendance at A&E has more than triple over the past 50 years, the study says, rising up to 373 out every 1,000 of the population in 2015-16.

The study looked at anonymous data from individual patients and linked their GP and A&E records over a two year period, focusing on the Clinical Commissioning Groups of Newham, Tower Hamlets and City and Hackney.

Since it focused on east London, an inner-city area with pockets of deprivation and a large ethnic minority population, it is not representative of the country as a whole, the authors warn.

Anonymised records for more than 800,000 patients were examined (Chris Radburn/PA)
Anonymised records for more than 800,000 patients were examined (Chris Radburn/PA)

Attendance rates at emergency departments for patients from the most deprived areas were found to be 52% higher than those from the least deprived.

Patients access to GPs - or lack of it - did not predict how likely they were to end up at A&E instead, the study said.

Dr Hull continued: "People in the most socially deprived areas develop long term health conditions 10 years earlier than those who are least deprived.

"These factors combine to put pressure on emergency departments."

Read Full Story

FROM OUR PARTNERS